News U Can Use – March

These news items are brought to you by Kuk & Baldwin:

MORE THAN A SMILE.     An extensive survey found that some 70% of individuals went to a dentist at lest twice in the previous year for a checkup and/or cleaning, while another 19% went once and 11% didn’t go at all.   But most of today’s dentists go beyond the smile and routinely look for oral clues to a number of other problems, including diabetes, possible cardiovascular problems, Addison’s disease, HIV, yeast infections, and even iron-deficiency. Should dentists advertise such so-called “practice drift”?   Maybe not specifically, but a YP ad can include copy that refers to the dentist’s website for information on the overall health benefits of oral checkups (Consumer Reports, 2/12; Personal Journal, 12/27/11).

RESTAURANT SALES.     The National Restaurant Association says US restaurant sales on a typical day come to $1.7 billion.   If you multiply that by 300 days, annual revenue tops $500 billion – an average of over $4300 a year per household spent in restaurants ranging from quick-serve to take-out to fine dining.   Thus, if your YP covers a 30,000 household area, you can tell restaurant advertisers that locals spend as much as $129 million a year on restaurant food – plenty of reason to advertise in the YP (Restaurant News, 12/19/11)

CALL TRACKING.     As you know, an advertiser can test several ad media at the same time with multiple RCF numbers.  Now, it’s easier to do that with call-tracking companies like LogMyCalls.com that let advertisers choose a toll-free, local, or vanity number for each ad medium they use.   For example, a LogMyCalls.com spokesman lists 27 media in which one of their numbers can track calls.   Here is what he says about YP:  “Listing your business in the YP is a necessity.   Why?   Because many people still use the phone book and an increasing number of people search the YP online.”   You can recommend call tracking to your advertisers – but never without an ROI projection (Auto Pro Workshop, 12/21/11).

Find out how to be at the top of your sales performance by clicking on www.kukbaldwin.com.

Other recent media/advertising news:

ZenithOptimedia Believes Global Ad Growth Coming
ZenithOptimedia has updated its December global ad spending forecast, raising it to 4.8% to $489 billion this year. Breaking it down, trouble in Europe continues to keep spending down, Asia and Latin America will offset that with higher gains.  For the US, projections are call for 5.3% growth in 2013 and 6.1% in 2014. (Source)

More US Advertising Estimates — Kantar: U.S. Ad Spend Dropped 1% in Q4
Kantar Media revised its estimate of U.S. ad spending for 2011, pegging an increase at 0.8%, to $144 billion. The rate of spending growth slowed across media, including cable TV, network TV, search and digital display. Data also indicate that spending declined 1% in the fourth quarter. (Source)

At $40 billion in U.S. Online Spending, Print Gets Passed
This article came out a few months ago, but I thought this was worth noting.  Online advertising is expected to approach a $40 billion watermark by year’s end, zipping ahead of newspapers and magazines for the first time, per eMarketer’s estimate. Double-digit growth through 2014 is expected to yield more than $52 billion then as advertisers become increasingly comfortable with integrated efforts. (Source)

More on Online Advertising:   The $684 billion Internet economy
We all know that the Internet has grown to be a major media and impact on our lives.  Just how big?  At $684 billion in 2010, the Internet has grown to the point that it contributes more to the U.S. economy than the agricultural, construction and education sectors as well as the federal government itself, according to a Boston Consulting Group study. The 4.7% the Internet generated ties Japan for fourth place in its percentage of gross domestic product, behind the U.K., South Korea and China. (Source)

As a point of reference, in 2009 we talked about how the Yellow Page industry has nearly a trillion dollars in economic impact in the local communities we serve (link to article).

Trust:  Millennials have money but don’t trust TV, can’t recall ads
Print Yellow Pages has always had a super high trust level amoung users.  While the millennial generation commands $170 billion in purchasing power (per a comScore report) and are very comfortable with computer technology and mobile media, they are very wary of traditional television advertising and harder to influence than other generations. (Source)

Americans are driving their cars longer than ever
Noticed more clunkers on the road?  There is a reason why — the length of car ownership among American drivers has reached an all-time high of 71 months, according to an R.L. Polk study. The trend is attributed to the economy, better warranties, and higher reliability which are collectively are negatively impact new-car sales. My 2005 F-150 is paid for.  Not sure I will be shopping for $500+ month payment for a new vehicle anytime soon.  For Yellow Page publishers – your repair headings are going to become even more important to local consumers. (Source)

 

People – March

We are a little behind in our updates of  people in the Yellow Pages industry.  This regular blog sponsored by Hawthorne Executive Search  is all about people in the Yellow Pages industry. If you have news you want to share about someone that is involved in the Yellow Pages industry (including retirees) that we should all know about, drop us a line and tell us how they are doing. Send your submissions to ken@yptalk.com.

Neal Polachek:

BIA/Kelsey has announced that Neal Polachek, president of for the past three years, has left the company. Rick Ducey has been is promoted to managing director supervising research, Continuous Advisory Services (CAS) programs and consulting services.  Matt Booth was named chief strategy officer. Matt will continue to run the Interactive Local Media (ILM) advisory service and provide leadership for consulting practices and conferences. Bobbi Loy-Luster has been given an expanded role as vp of client services, including overseeing CAS programs and the company’s new competitive benchmarking. Peter Krasilovsky, vice president and program director, will now serve an expanded role as conference chairman.

Peter Broadbent:

Peter Broadbent has been named vice president, investor relations & marketing, at Photronics Inc., a leader in supplying photomask-based imaging solutions for global electronics and display industries.  Broadbent had spent 25 years at Wahlstrom Group, where he was CEO. He served on the Local Search Association Board of Directors, as well as the National Marketing Division Advisory Council.

Matt Anderson:

Yellow Pages publisher Yell has appointed Matt Anderson to the new role of chief strategy and business development officer.  His task will be to spearhead the group’s strategy of providing digital services to small and medium-sized businesses, as its sales of paper directories decline.

Anderson had worked with Yell on this strategy, which was unveiled last July, while he was a senior adviser at US consultancy Booz & Company.

Yell chief executive Mike Pocock said Anderson had ‘played an instrumental role’ in developing the new strategy.

Linda Kennedy:

Yell also announced the appointment of Linda Kennedy to the new role of Group Human Resources Director. Kennedy will lead organizational change and support the integration of Yell’s global business in the UK, US, Spain and some countries in Latin America.

Kennedy joins Yell from UK mobile operator Everything Everywhere, the joint venture between Orange and T Mobile; she held the role of chief change officer, reporting to the CEO and delivered the integration of the two businesses.

Previously, she was group HRD at international service company Serco, where among her responsibilities were the development of a people strategy and the implementation of a leadership and talent management framework.

Based at Yell’s corporate headquarters in Reading, UK, Kennedy will report to Mike Pocock, Yell’s CEO. She will be responsible for building a group-wide HR capability to support the executive group and deliver organizational change.

Bruce Akhurst, Rick Ellis:

Bruce Akhurst who headed Telstra’s Yellow Pages directory business, Sensis will leave the company in May.  Telstra Chief Executive David Thodey said in a statement that, despite a challenging print environment, Sensis had managed to maintain strong print revenues compared with its global peers and had started its transition into a fully digital capable media business.

The company said Rick Ellis, group managing director of Telstra Digital Media, would be acting chief executive of Sensis while a replacement for Akhurst was sought.

“I have enjoyed my time as CEO of Sensis. It is time now for a change and I look forward to exploring new opportunities,” he said in a statement

Sebastien Provencher:

Sebastien Provencher, one of the most prolific bloggers in the industry, has announced he is leaving Needium, the company he co-founded. Provencher recently disclosed his future plans: “…As a next step in my career, I’m looking for international experience. I’d like to work in Europe or in the United States as a senior exec in a media/Internet company (large or small). I bring with me solid experience in product management, business development, Internet strategy, social media and management.”  You can reach him at sprovencher@gmail.com.

He would be a great addition to your team…

Do Digital Only Sales Teams Outperform All Others?

Most local media advertising providers now use a single sales force to sell both their newer digital products and their traditional print advertising products.  But according to a new report from Borrell Associates, that could be a shortsighted strategy.  The company identified what it believes are major differences between companies that employ digital-only sales forces and those that instead employ a single sales (and content) force strategy which can do it all.

First, the Borrell study noted that an increasing number of companies are consolidating “offline” (let’s just call them “traditional” product sales) and online sales reps into a single unified team selling both types of products.  The number of digital-only sales reps — those employed by traditional  media companies (newspapers, radio and TV, but not Yellow Pages) has dropped from 60% in August of 2009 to 46%.

According to the report, online sites that do employ online-only account executives (AE’s) “outperform those without by a factor of 2.5” in terms of gross online revenue per sales rep. The difference is even more dramatic at TV stations – those TV stations that do employ online-only AE’s, do see them showing results which are three times the gross revenue of stations that don’t. Borrell’s bottom line conclusion:  “(its) clear that having a staff dedicated to selling online advertising—and combining it with the efforts of the legacy media sales force—drives more digital revenues.”  However, note that the research makes no mention of the impact on the traditional products sales of having some digital-only reps.

Borrell also looked at how local advertising media companies organizing their sales reps, and found that the most successful model tends to be “separate digital units with dotted lines”—companies, which employ both traditional and digital-only sellers, but also have a separate digital division responsible for hitting digital revenue goals and reporting to a separate manager.  Borrell reports “…many of these operations saw revenue growth in the 40 to 60 percent range in 2011, while average market growth for local online advertising was 15 percent.  The reason is no mystery:  with a unit that has sole responsibility for just digital sales, goals and lines of responsibility don’t get tangled up in debates about the legacy media sales problems.”

Borrell is charging $995 for the full 27 page report.

Our Takeaway:

I find some parts of the conclusions to be flawed analysis.  First, logic will tell you that if an AE only sales one product (digital in this case), their percentage of sales will be higher then a salesperson who sells many products, with digital being just one of them.  If they are truly providing a solution that meets the advertiser’s needs, sometimes it may not include digital products.  Any responsible, good AE would respond to the buying needs of the client with a recommendation that provides the greatest ROI for the client, independent of the product set.

There have been numerous attempts in the past by Yellow Pages publishers to try a wide range of sales organization and product strategies – digital only, full suite, vertical market segment focused, etc., etc.

What’s your view?  Which works best, and more importantly, why?

 

Why go to the “Search Starts Here” conference?

A couple of weeks ago we provided some information on the upcoming 2012 Local Search Association Conference in this article.  The event will take place in Boca Raton, Florida on April 21 to 24th.  We recently caught up with Association President Neg Norton to find out how the Search Starts Here themed conference is shaping up.  Since we are less than two months from the event, Neg provided some additional insights to why people should plan to attend this event.

First off, they have lined up a wide range of speakers from across the local search and directory publishing industry.  Neg notes that “it’s a strong agenda and we’re doing a few things differently this year.  We have lots of different topics and more presentation formats than in prior years.”  For example, some recent additions to the speaker lineup include Peter McDonald, CEO, SuperMedia (and Chairman of the Local Search Association);  Alfred Mockett, CEO, Dex One; Ursula Worth, head of directories and web hosting partnerships, Google; Trevor Nadeau, managing director, Yellow Medya (Turkey); Chris Silver Smith, President, Argent Media; Peter Buxton, Buxton Independent Consulting (Germany) and Krishna Pillai, COO and Founder Convergent Media.

At a time when travel budgets are tight, why attend this conference?  Neg summed it up in a concise but valuable comment – “you’ll walk away with actionable insights you can put in play the first day you are back on the job.  There will be insights from several pieces of research –– forward-looking analysis of relevant market data from both LSA and BIA/Kelsey, vSplash analysis of 500,000 websites from around the world (invitation only session), insights from local media sales reps, and more.”  Clearly, the ROI for coming to the conference is real.

If you go a little deeper in the agenda, you will find keynote speeches, panels, and fireside chats.  Some highlights:

• Neg and Peter McDonald will provide a state of the association and industry overview,
• Google will be talking about what they see on social, local and mobile products.
• SMG Directory Marketing will have one of their clients focus on how a sophisticated national advertiser builds their local media plan.
• Axiom Sales Force Development will host a session focused on tools and techniques for effective sales coaching.
• A “lightening round” from new supplier members with new technologies and applications who will have just a short 4 minutes to talk about the newest stuff they are working on and rolling out.

The LSA conference will also continue the format they have used successfully for two prior conferences – Strategic Exchange Sessions where suppliers can get private meetings with key prospects. Neg indicated we can expect to see some new companies in the Strategic Exchange Sessions this year—companies like Adflexer, Willow Tree Apps, Axiom Sales Force Development as well as some faces from last year such as Yellow Magic, PlaceLinks, The Andersen Group, Amdocs, Acxiom—-to name just a few.

If you are looking to meet and talk with new companies, potential new partners, the conference has a number of social networking opportunities.  Last year the conference attracted around 400 attendees.  This year’s event is on track to reach the same levels.  Given the expansion of the association beyond the traditional directory space, expect a noticeable increase in “non-traditional” companies.  Many will be companies the industry is already doing business with; and others are looking to enter the space with their new products and services.  Here are some of the formal networking events scheduled:

• There is the annual golf tournament on Sunday morning, a more casual environment for making and building great connections.
• The Industry Excellence Awards will be held Sunday evening, with a reception that follows allows for mixing and mingling over drinks and light refreshments.
• The President’s New Member and Associate Member Reception (invitation only) offers a chance to meet the newest      members of the association, as well as those who support the local search industry.
• The Poolside Party Monday night offers a lively environment for conversation over dinner and cocktails.

And with all that, it is Florida, so attendees can maybe get a chance to enjoy the sunshine and great weather they have this time of year.  This truly is no long just a yellow pages conference; it really is a true local search happening….

Go register now at: http://bit.ly/wdQ4Ux. Tell them YP Talk sent you…

Get an Objection? Raise the Price

Mark Hunter, who calls himself “The Sales Hunter”, (nice play on words) writes a sales motivation blog at thesaleshunter.com.  One of his sales training tips, “#370: What to do with an Objection” was recently brought to my attention by the folks from Sunshine Pages (thank you Wayne)

In this tip Hunter turns around the normal assumption most people have that an objection means there is a problem and hence, a discount is needed to keep the conversation and ultimately the sale moving.  Hunter believes just the opposite.  When the customer voices an objection, that means they’re thinking and engaged with the sales process/discussion. It also means there must be at least some level of interest in buying since you weren’t asked to leave.  If anything, increase the price with each objection.

My observation has been that the best, most successful sales reps view objections as an opportunity, and not the roadblock that lesser reps see it as.  Could it be that objections are really the customer trying to come up with reasons to convince THEMSELVES that they shouldn’t be buying?  If it’s just an objection, and not a “not interested”/don’t like you/don’t like your product type comment, then isn’t an objection almost a buying signal?

Of course skilled reps know they need to keep drilling down to find what the TRUE objection is, most likely around where this business owner wants their business to be in 2, 3, or even 4 years from now.  Again my observation is that the issue is the ROI or value for what they are about to spend.  This becomes the opportunity for the rep to begin presenting call-tracking data, testimonials from other advertisers, and usage data that reinforces the results that ad program can bring to their business.

As one of the reps from the Sunshine Pages commented:  “…I liked objections—they made me learn more about my customer’s business, honed my selling skills, and made me memorize stats regarding his heading prior to going into the appointment.  I got to a point where I could almost anticipate the objection and already had the answer to it.  This comes with time but the sooner one learns to do this, the more successful one will be.”

Also note the reps comments bring you back to the issue of being prepped BEFORE going into an account.  Do you have an A, B, and C plan already prepared?  Have you looked to see what they are doing online?  Do you have a fresh piece of spec art ready? And most importantly, do you have 4 or 5 new concepts/ideas you can recommend to that business that will give them a reason to invest in your products or services??

So next time the customer throws you an objection, take the time to dig down on the objection by first validating if the objection is real. Then use questions to further engage the customer and have them build more on their objection, especially if you’re confident you can respond favorably to the objection (hint:  because you did your prep work).

 

By getting the customer to build on their objection, you’re getting them to be even more engaged and connected with the recommendation you’ve offered.  Don’t start discounting as soon as that first objection comes out.  Turn it around and keep moving to a closing statement on your “A” plan, which should be your highest priced plan.

 

Besides, what’s the worst thing that can happen?  Your close attempt is rejected.  If that happens, time to respond to them with another question, getting them to explain to you even more where the fear(s) are.

Separating Perception from Reality – Truth is Power….

“No one uses print Yellow Pages.”  “Everyone uses a mobile phone, or just does a Google search to find information.”  “Why are these books still being printed when no one ever uses them?”

Sound familiar?  How can a publisher, a sales manager, or a rep respond to this constant barrage of wild assumptions they face?  The answer is fairly simple – separate the facts from the perception …in a believable and compelling way.

The best way to do that is to engage a company like Market Authority, to help get to those facts. Market Authority offers irrefutable data, analysis and reporting on how people really look for a local business when making a buying decision. Then they bring this data to you and your sales people in a very powerful sales training. The research fully dispels the prevalent “urban myth” that the Internet is the only source for local search information.

I know, this sounds too good to be true.  But consider that Market Authority has conducted interviews with over 270,000 consumers across the world in the last 20 months, studying their technology and media habits, especially when they are looking for a local business.  The sheer volume of this research has certainly been the largest and most extensive directional media study ever performed on this issue.

Now if you‘re like me, you are always suspicious about the research methodology that is used since the worst thing that can happen is to go to market with data that has been skewed or fudged.  I challenged Steve Sitton, the CEO of Market Authority on this very issue.  His response was reassuring:

“…Our team utilizes state-of-the-art research techniques, statistical analysis, and normalization to gather accurate data.  To start, the phone numbers are randomized. We make the line of questions as concise and neutral as possible.  We conduct the interviews over the most neutral device possible …the phone. Obviously, you can’t do this type research just on the Internet since the results would be ridiculously skewed towards the digital side, which is why these other studies keep showing that digital usage is so over stated.”

When you get to see the results, they are clearly shocking.   “The misconception that print yellow pages is dead is prevalent all over the industrial world,” said Sitton.  “While more and more people are using the Internet either from a terminal or a smartphone to find SMEs (small to medium size businesses), the reality is, print yellow pages still remains the dominant way consumers are finding a business in the US in 2012. This is also true in the UK and Australia.”

Market Authority then takes this data to the critical next level that local businesses still need to hear:  Approx. 65% of all money currently being spent in the US by local consumers is finding its way to those local markets through print yellow page products. Yes, that percent has been coming down in recent years, but the print products still rule.

These results support the argument of just how destructive the efforts are by the city of San Francisco (a local government that has a political agenda) to require opt-in for printed phonebooks, because they assume that no one uses print. (Sitton calls this ‘the virus of misperception’).  Market Authority has recently completed an exhaustive study of the San Francisco Bay area which shows that nearly 70% of residents still use a printed phonebook at least some of the time. That same study shows that the average person living in the Bay Area thinks print is only used by 20% of the people. The reality of print usage is more than three times that of the perception.

“The bottom line here,” says Sitton, “is the study indicates that currently nearly 50% of money spent as a result of a direct search for a local business on the part of San Francisco Bay Area consumers comes from a look-up in a printed directory. To seriously impede distribution of printed Yellow Pages directories (through opt-in legislation) would surely cause a vast reduction in the effectiveness of the current most cost effective means of gaining new leads for San Francisco Bay Area businesses. This would be damaging to locally-owned small and medium businesses, especially in this precarious economy.”

Given the current wave of anti-print noise that many consumers are experiencing, we asked what the company does to quantify the whole value of a print directory with an opt-out/opt-in question in their research.  Sitton indicated:

“We asked people in the San Francisco Bay area who report using a printed directory; (68% of the total) if a phone book were no longer automatically delivered and they had to make a call to receive one, would they do so? Nearly 50% said they would not make that call. This implies that print would lose a high percentage of its greatest fans overnight in a Opt-in world.”

Results in the UK where tilted about 8 points more towards digital, but remember their starting point was very different than it was in the US.  Currently many publishers there are already close to a 50/50 split on print/digital revenues, which Sitton says, “Is more because they’ve undersold the print than that they have effectively sold the digital”.

Steve Sitton brings an interesting background to this effort.  He has been in the directional media business for over 25 years, owning and operating 5 different Yellow Page companies during his career as a publisher.  While leading Golden State Directories in California, as early as 2007 he started to hear about the Internet from advertisers.  Immediately advertisers already thought that 50% of the money they were getting was from Internet searches.  The company started some initial research where they interviewed 1500 people door-to-door about whether people were using print or Internet. The results were so over the top in favor of print, it was alarming.  In 2007, nearly 90% of the leads businesses were getting were still coming from the print Yellow Pages.  Internet was only generating less than 12%.

Market Authority, Inc. was founded in 2009 by Steve Sitton.  Using his industry experience, he shaped the research methods to exacting efficiency. All markets they research are scanned for behavioral, demographic, technological, and directional media usage patterns. Market Authority, Inc. performs and records the research, gathers and analyzes the data, with state-of-the art precision; and now is able to define the roles the Internet and print play in today’s directional media industry.

Market Authority, Inc has also become an industry leader in training.  Sitton says: “We are a sales empowerment/market research company. That is a new mix…and it really works. I believe we have the most powerful Yellow Pages training in industry history.”  To date, Market Authority has studied over 300 cities.  Sitton and senior trainer, Layne Snyder, have conducted nearly 170 trainings with over 6500 sales people and managers in the US and the UK.

Given this shift in usage, we asked Sitton where he thought the industry should be heading.  His analysis about what to do with print was simple but direct:

• Use larger type so that Baby Boomers and Senior’s can read it. Tag this on the cover.
• In high tech areas, reduce  copies by target-distributing only those over 45 years old. (Let younger people who want a book pick them up at drop points). Use the money saved by  the reduction to make a better product for 45+ people.
• Research all your markets  and share this research vigorously with every advertiser.

He commented deeper on these suggestions:

“The key for print is not how many people are using it, but who.  If you look at how business owners target the market, they are generally less sophisticated on the demographic breakdowns.  That’s when the sales rep needs to use these results to help the business owner focus their advertising spend.  Nearly 70% of the dollars spent across all size markets in the US are coming from Baby Boomers and Senior’s who still use print to find a business nearly 70% of time (on the average). This is the 70/70 rule. It means, even in urban areas (like San Francisco), a significant amount of money is still coming from print.  The advertiser needs to clearly know who they are selling to and who is their target.”

About Market Authority, Inc.:

Market Authority combines the most targeted print/digital research in the world and the most effective sales training in Yellow Pages industry. Sales reps will understand how to quickly and powerfully get the message across to business owners.  As former Yellow Pages publishers, Market Authority understands what empowers sales representatives, and what closes more sales.  Our nationally successful program renews your confidence and shows your sales representatives how to leverage the results in their local markets. Learn More…                       

For more information on Market Authority, Inc.’s market studies, contact Kari Simpson, at 816-537-7950.

Is advertising in the Super Bowl really worth it??

One of the questions I have been asking for years is whether advertising at the Super Bowl is really worth it.  There is no doubt that this annual event, almost a holiday onto itself now, has a huge viewing audience. The commercials that run during the game have almost become an event onto themselves, and have occasionally been more entertaining than the game itself.  For days after, they are analyzed, rated, and commented on year after year after year.  But does that mean that spending over $3,500,000 on average for 30 seconds really results in more sales?

The raw viewing numbers are huge.  For this year’s event, NBC (Nielsen actually) estimated an average of 111.3 million total viewers tuned in to watch the underdog New York Giants hold off the New England Patriots 21-17 in a seesaw game that went down to the final moments.  Another calculation was that an estimated that 177 million viewers, or more than 56% of the current U.S. population, watched at least six minutes of the game. For comparison, that “reach” was  comparable to an entire cycle of the Olympics, spread over two weeks of days/nights.

However, even with those numbers, is it really worth it?  When you consider that over 300 million people live in America, that means just 35% of the country tuned into the game (and the commercials).  And if you were at a Super Bowl party, how many of the people there really watched the game or the commercials closely?

In past Super Bowls, one of my criticisms of the advertising was I saw little connection made between spending those millions and actual sales generated.  You will find very little solid evidence that companies actually measure sales as a result of the advertising.  Instead, they will talk about eyeballs, reach, CPM’s, and all kinds of things that marketing people and ad agencies will use to justify spending the money.  You should also note that the $3.5 million cost of the ad this year does NOT include the production costs to make it.

For example, the online website registration company of “Go Daddy” has become well known for their solicitous, high sexual in nature ads.  Here is the best “results” I could find about how well their ads translated into actual sales (I added the underlining to key comments):

“…Go Daddy says that Go Daddy’s “Body Paint” ad accounted for a tremendous Internet spike during the game that coincides with a peak point in Web traffic, as reported by Akamai Technologies, a company that monitored Internet usage during the Super Bowl. Go Daddy did not reveal though how big of a spike we are talking about...”

Notice they do not say how many actual sales results from their ads.

The good news for marketers is that with the advent of newer technologies such as mobile text marketing and Twitter, companies can now get some immediate indication of the impact these ads had.  For example, this year on an ad shown during the game, the National Football League asked contest participants to text a message to register for a $1 million contest running next season. The “NFL Perfect Challenge” contest drew 1.7 million text-message responses. The NFL says the “…conversion rate was higher than the industry average….” (Source).  Once again, I see words like “conversion rate”, but not the words “sales”.  I was one of the 1.7 million that did join the contest.  I got one text message back from the NFL but haven’t heard a thing since then.

The other quick response darling, Twitter, said they hit a peak of 12K tweets per second during Super Bowl (Source).   Two questions from that factoid:  1) did any sales result from all of those tweets?, and 2) does anyone ever just talk to anyone any more (or is my age just showing)??

So next time you are with a potential Yellow Page advertiser (as in print, online, or mobile) ask them whether they would love to advertise at the Super Bowl (assuming that money was not an issue).  When they start foaming at the mouth, take them thru a reality ROI calculation vs. your product and help them come back to earth.  Because at ROI’s of AT LEAST 10-to-1, nothing beats Yellow Pages (again talking print, online, or mobile).  Not even the Super Bowl…